When I saw Rob Marshall’s Chicago on my nineteenth birthday, it was a revelation. I’ve always been enamored with the Victorian Age, but after watching the film, I wanted to be a 1920s Jazz Killer. I was ready to slink around in sequins and fishnet stockings, break hearts, and get away with murder. I’ve been fascinated with violent women ever since. Little did I know that my own fervor paled in comparison to the real appetite Chicago had for murderesses in 1924.
The Girls of Murder City: Fame, Lust, and the Beautiful Killers who Inspired Chicago by Douglas Perry exposes the true stories of a string of female-perpetrated murders that rocked Chicago. Belva Gaertner, a striking divorcee and former cabaret entertainer, used her sense of style and her ex-husband’s fortune to evade justice. In a neighboring cell, Beulah Annan, both an admitted adulteress and the prettiest woman in jail, changed her story until she found one that showed her in the best light. The facts of the period swirl like a three-ring circus with the murderesses making a play for public sympathy, the city scrambling for a conviction, and the newspapers competing for coverage. Against a landscape of corruption and immorality, pretty women got away with murder by winning the hearts of all-male juries. Not even the men they cuckolded turned against them.
Enter Maurine Watkins, an unlikely crime reporter writing for the Chicago Tribune. Her cynicism for the system jived with the paper’s notorious “hanging” reputation. Her peers, mostly members of a group known as “sob sisters,” excused the women’s crimes as a result of exigent circumstances and glamorized their lives. Maurine alone viewed the women, and the system that would let them off, as disgusting. She eventually funneled her bitterness into a hit Broadway satire, Chicago.
The book reads like a novel, partly because the facts are so absurd, but mostly thanks to Perry’s engaging style. The story doesn’t lag for a moment. It’s full of salacious details about sex, illicit booze and jazz. Beulah danced around to her Victrola while her boyfriend, shot in the back, bled out on the floor. With newspapers chronicling every detail of the murderesses’ lives and escapades, Perry had plenty of source material to draw from. Fans of the musical will be interested in the background information, but there’s plenty to enjoy regardless. If you like scandal and ladies behaving badly, you’ll love the Girls of Murder City.









