
When the man from Primrose Lane, previously only glimpsed shuffling through town with mittens on, even in the height of summer, is found brutally murdered, no one suspects his death is connected to the horrific abduction and murders of innocent and striking red-haired girls.
His identity becomes a crucial key to unravelling the endlessly perplexing mysteries in true crime writer James Renner’s debut novel, The Man from Primrose Lane.
Four years after his murder the case is still ice cold in Akron, Ohio. The protagonist, true crime writer and single father, David Neff, is lured out of his own reclusive state, a reaction to the suicide of his red-haired wife immediately following the birth of their son, by the puzzling facts of the man from Primrose Lane’s demise. A connection between his tormented wife and the town hermit arises, blowing the case, and David’s comfortable numbness, wide open.
David Neff is a tragic character. He’s plagued with an obsessive nature. Four years after his wife’s suicide he’s still haunted by their star-crossed love. He finds himself tempted by a younger woman, who though she has a dramatically different personality, bears a strong resemblance to the mother of his son.
Much more than women, he finds himself consumed by solving crimes. Left with a raging case of post traumatic stress disorder following the completion of his first book which required him to delve into the disturbing world of trafficking pedophiles, David is not sure he’ll ever be able to cope without medication. And he’s frightened when he sees the same obsessive qualities in his young son who spends hours building elaborate machines inspired by the board game Mouse Trap.
In many ways David is his own worst enemy. He isn’t so different from the sociopaths lurking in the background of the story, waiting for the opportunity to snatch up young girls. His obsessions lead him to act impulsively, often with disastrous results. And the novel raises the question, how different is David from the loathsome stalkers he profiles? In another lifetime, could he be one of them? Or has he already crossed over, responsible for the double murder of his wife and the man from Primrose Lane?
The quantum concept of infinite worlds with infinite outcomes is deftly explored with surprising results when science fiction elements are woven into the gritty crime mystery. The novel is a complex tapestry of genres, plotlines and timelines. Seemingly random diversions and non-sequiturs pop up along the way only to be brilliantly revealed as crucial puzzle pieces later. In the hands of a less capable writer this tale would have been a jumbled mess. But Renner delivers an incredibly satisfying experience that I am still pondering a week after finishing the book. Frankly, I’m amazed at how well it all came together.
I recommend this novel to active readers who enjoy dark, uncompromising and provocative fiction.
The Man from Primrose Lane: A Novel by James Renner, is available from Amazon for $16.12.
*I received this book from the publisher, but was under no obligation to post a good review.








































































